Social Media Discovery: Can the Other Side Access Your Private Accounts?
Litigation By Binnall Law Group - 2026/10/22 at 10:30pm
Many individuals assume that setting a social media account to “private” will keep its contents out of a lawsuit. However, privacy settings do not necessarily protect social media content from discovery.
Posts, photographs, and messages that you believed only your friends could see may ultimately be produced to the opposing party. How you handle that content once a dispute arises can significantly affect the outcome of your case.
Can Private Social Media Posts Be Used as Evidence in a Lawsuit?
Courts do not afford social media content special protection merely because it sits behind a privacy setting.
In federal civil litigation, social media evidence is subject to the same general discovery standards as other information. Nonprivileged material may be discoverable when it is relevant to a party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case.
For example, private photographs depicting physical activity may be relevant in a personal injury lawsuit, while messages discussing the events underlying a dispute may be relevant in a civil litigation matter.
This does not mean the opposing party is automatically entitled to unrestricted access to your social media accounts. Discovery requests must comply with applicable rules and should be appropriately tailored to the issues in dispute.
Courts may limit requests that are overly broad or unduly burdensome, but a privacy setting alone generally will not prevent the discovery of relevant information.
Can the Other Side Subpoena Facebook, Instagram, or Other Social Media Platforms?
One might ask why the opposing party cannot simply subpoena the social media platform directly.
The federal Stored Communications Act generally restricts providers such as Meta and X from disclosing the contents of users’ protected electronic communications in response to civil subpoenas, subject to statutory exceptions.
Consequently, discovery requests for social media content are frequently directed to the parties themselves rather than the platforms.
As a party to litigation, you may be required to preserve and produce relevant social media content within your possession, custody, or control. These obligations cannot necessarily be avoided simply because the information is stored on a third-party platform.
What Happens If You Delete Social Media Posts During Litigation?
Virginia offers a cautionary example of the consequences of attempting to conceal or destroy social media evidence.
In Allied Concrete Co. v. Lester, a wrongful death plaintiff deleted photographs from his Facebook account after his attorney directed him to “clean up” his page.
The trial court imposed a combined $722,000 in monetary sanctions against the plaintiff and his attorney for misconduct associated with the discovery process. The attorney also subsequently received a five-year suspension of his law license.
The case demonstrates that deleting relevant social media evidence during litigation can carry serious consequences, including monetary sanctions, damage to a party’s credibility, and adverse evidentiary rulings.
In some circumstances, the attempt to conceal unfavorable evidence can prove more damaging than the evidence itself.
How Should You Handle Social Media During a Lawsuit?
If you are involved in litigation, or reasonably anticipate a lawsuit, you should assume that relevant social media activity may eventually be reviewed by opposing counsel and potentially presented in court.
Several precautions can help protect your interests:
Preserve existing content. Do not delete, deactivate, or modify accounts or posts that may contain relevant evidence without first consulting your attorney.
Be cautious about new posts. Avoid discussing the dispute, your injuries, finances, the opposing party, or other issues relevant to the litigation.
Review privacy settings with your attorney. Adjusting privacy settings may be permissible, but doing so will not shield otherwise discoverable information.
Be careful with unfamiliar requests. Avoid accepting friend or follow requests from individuals you do not recognize.
Disclose your accounts to your attorney. Inform your legal team about relevant social media profiles, including dormant accounts and messaging applications, so that potentially discoverable information can be identified and properly preserved.
These precautions are especially important once litigation is underway or reasonably foreseeable, when the duty to preserve potentially relevant evidence may already apply.
Protecting Your Interests During Social Media Discovery
Social media can provide valuable evidence in civil litigation, but it can also create unexpected challenges for individuals who are unfamiliar with the discovery process.
Privacy settings do not guarantee that posts, photographs, or messages will remain confidential during a lawsuit. Understanding your obligations and taking appropriate steps to preserve evidence can help avoid costly mistakes.
If you are facing a legal dispute and have questions about your social media accounts, contact Binnall Law Group before deleting content, modifying an account, or responding to a discovery request. Our litigation team can help you understand your obligations and protect your interests throughout the legal process.
